Difference between revisions of "X3D Plugfest"
From Web3D.org
(2012) |
(move instructions to submitters to general position) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | == 2012 | + | == 2012 Interoperability == |
=== Resources === | === Resources === | ||
There are many resources for interoperability available: | There are many resources for interoperability available: | ||
* Website "New to X3D" | * Website "New to X3D" | ||
| − | * X3D Resources | + | * X3D Resources |
| − | * Player support | + | * Player support |
| − | * Tool support | + | * Tool support |
| − | * X3D Examples | + | * X3D Examples |
| − | * Nightly builds | + | * Nightly builds |
=== Open Source === | === Open Source === | ||
Open Source codebases make achieving interoperability even easier too: | Open Source codebases make achieving interoperability even easier too: | ||
| − | * Xj3D | + | * Xj3D |
| − | * X3DOM | + | * X3DOM |
* FreeWRL/FreeX3D | * FreeWRL/FreeX3D | ||
| − | * Castle | + | * Castle |
| − | * OpenVRML | + | * OpenVRML |
| − | * others... | + | * others... |
===Quality Assurance (QA)=== | ===Quality Assurance (QA)=== | ||
| − | |||
The [https://savage.nps.edu/X3dValidator X3D Validator] provides a server-based suite of tests to help ensure the quality of X3D scenes and metadata. Validation tests include: | The [https://savage.nps.edu/X3dValidator X3D Validator] provides a server-based suite of tests to help ensure the quality of X3D scenes and metadata. Validation tests include: | ||
| − | * | + | * XML header and DOCTYPE checking for correct document headers |
| − | * | + | * Well-formed XML checking |
| − | * | + | * X3D DTD and XML Schema checking for valid X3D nodes, fields and values |
| − | * | + | * X3D Schematron rule checking to verify semantic correctness and detect internal-consistency problems |
| − | * | + | * X3D to ClassicVRML conversion checks a variety of legal X3D constructs |
| − | * | + | * Regular expression checking for malformed floating-point numbers and excess leading zeros |
| − | * | + | * X3D to XHTML conversion pretty-print listing to check online URL links, document ROUTE connections, and provide node tooltips |
=== Example scenes for this year === | === Example scenes for this year === | ||
| − | |||
* Extrusion: Moebius Strip Bushings | * Extrusion: Moebius Strip Bushings | ||
* ImageTexture TextureTransform | * ImageTexture TextureTransform | ||
* Web3D Time Line (both X3D and X3DOM) | * Web3D Time Line (both X3D and X3DOM) | ||
| − | * X3D for Advanced Modeling preview: | + | * X3D for Advanced Modeling preview: San Carlos Cathedral |
| − | + | ||
=== CAD group recommendations for export === | === CAD group recommendations for export === | ||
| Line 45: | Line 42: | ||
* Binary Compression | * Binary Compression | ||
| + | ==2010== | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
===2010 Plugfest Content - 24-29 July 2010 - Web3D Symposium, SIGGRAPH=== | ===2010 Plugfest Content - 24-29 July 2010 - Web3D Symposium, SIGGRAPH=== | ||
How about another Plugfest? | How about another Plugfest? | ||
| Line 74: | Line 54: | ||
==2009== | ==2009== | ||
| + | |||
===2009 Plugfest Content - June 2009 - Fraunhofer IGD, Darmstadt, Germany=== | ===2009 Plugfest Content - June 2009 - Fraunhofer IGD, Darmstadt, Germany=== | ||
{|{{prettytable}} | {|{{prettytable}} | ||
| Line 159: | Line 140: | ||
==2008== | ==2008== | ||
| + | |||
===2008 Plugfest - 9 August 2008 - Web3D Symposium=== | ===2008 Plugfest - 9 August 2008 - Web3D Symposium=== | ||
{|{{prettytable}} | {|{{prettytable}} | ||
| Line 216: | Line 198: | ||
*Extrusion Implementations | *Extrusion Implementations | ||
*Node fields on a proto declaration, copy or reference | *Node fields on a proto declaration, copy or reference | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Instructions to submitters== | ||
| + | Please upload your Plugfest content here. Be sure to create a single zip file with all the parts included. Each zip file will be verified for content. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The goal of the each X3D Plugfest is to foster interoperability between X3D players. Each Plugfest is a regular event that brings content authors, authoring tool vendors and browser implementers together to work on interoperability issues. Consistent quality for X3D content helps everyone. | ||
| + | |||
| + | This is the navigation home page for the upcoming X3D Plugfests. Content will be linked from this page for everyone's review. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Please note: Submitted .x3d files must be zipped before being uploaded. Alternatively, links to online content can be provided. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Description fields: Include a description of your content, or else a description of the problem and any results from the browsers you've tested. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Content Release Option: Specify whether the content can be released publicly or just distributed to browser implementers for testing. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Related links include: | ||
| + | *[[Player support for X3D components]] | ||
| + | *[[Tool support for X3D components]] | ||
Latest revision as of 06:28, 21 July 2013
2012 Interoperability
Resources
There are many resources for interoperability available:
- Website "New to X3D"
- X3D Resources
- Player support
- Tool support
- X3D Examples
- Nightly builds
Open Source
Open Source codebases make achieving interoperability even easier too:
- Xj3D
- X3DOM
- FreeWRL/FreeX3D
- Castle
- OpenVRML
- others...
Quality Assurance (QA)
The X3D Validator provides a server-based suite of tests to help ensure the quality of X3D scenes and metadata. Validation tests include:
- XML header and DOCTYPE checking for correct document headers
- Well-formed XML checking
- X3D DTD and XML Schema checking for valid X3D nodes, fields and values
- X3D Schematron rule checking to verify semantic correctness and detect internal-consistency problems
- X3D to ClassicVRML conversion checks a variety of legal X3D constructs
- Regular expression checking for malformed floating-point numbers and excess leading zeros
- X3D to XHTML conversion pretty-print listing to check online URL links, document ROUTE connections, and provide node tooltips
Example scenes for this year
- Extrusion: Moebius Strip Bushings
- ImageTexture TextureTransform
- Web3D Time Line (both X3D and X3DOM)
- X3D for Advanced Modeling preview: San Carlos Cathedral
CAD group recommendations for export
- CAD Interchange profile, includes simple CAD structure nodes
- 2D nodes
- NURBS
- Binary Compression
2010
2010 Plugfest Content - 24-29 July 2010 - Web3D Symposium, SIGGRAPH
How about another Plugfest?
- When/where? Web3D 2010 Symposium and/or SIGGRAPH 2010?
- Getting organized around priority "Bugs of the month" that we document for all active browsers
- Who is tracking each browser and reporting the bugs?
- Demo how to use X3D-Edit to launch one or many browsers at a time on individual test scenes
- How to best report and track status of successes and problems?
2009
2009 Plugfest Content - June 2009 - Fraunhofer IGD, Darmstadt, Germany
| X3D Scenes, X3D Viewers | Updated | Author | Content Description | Problem Description | Content Releasability |
| (earlier revision) "Web3D Timeline (aka X3D Timeline)" | 25 May 2009 | Anita Havele, Web3D Consortium | Outreach examples for Web3D Consortium | Prototype interoperability between browsers | Public |
| "simpleShader.zip" | 26 May 2009 | John Stewart, CRC Canada | GLSL Shader test that uses a modified "toon" shader; light intensity on Spheres is shown where the color is dependent on intensity; the intensity bounding values are passed into the shader | Should display on hardware supporting GLSL shaders; Spheres will be "ringed". On non-GLSL systems, Spheres will be a uniformly shaded light blue | Public |
| Media:UrlInProtoTest.zip | 12 June 2009 | Patrick Dähne, Fraunhofer IGD | The X3D spec does not specify how to resolve relative URLs in EXTERNPROTOs. Some X3D Browsers resolve them relative to the EXTERNPROTO declaration, some to the EXTERNPROTO instantiation. | Open the file "UrlInProtoTest.wrl" in different browsers. Some will show yellow textured boxes, and some will show cyan textured boxes. Which behaviour is correct? | Public |
2009 Plugfest Content - March 2009 - NASA Ames, California
| X3D Scenes, X3D Viewers | Updated | Author | Content Description | Problem Description | Content Releasability |
| HelloWorld.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | Hello World simple scene (example image) | Quality of Sphere geometry, Text alignment, default X3D navigation mode is EXAMINE | Public |
| (earlier revision) Web3dLogo.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Anita Havele, Web3D Consortium | Outreach examples for Web3D Consortium | Simple polygonal text geometry | Public |
| "Web3D Timeline (aka X3D Timeline)" | 21 February 2009 | Anita Havele, Web3D Consortium | Outreach examples for Web3D Consortium | Prototype interoperability between browsers | Public |
| LineProperties.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | Material support (example image: LineProperties ) | Demonstrate lineType capabilities | Public |
| FillProperties.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | Material support (example image: FillProperties) | Demonstrate hatchStyle capabilities | Public |
| SpringExamples.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | Universal Media Materials examples | Proper rendering of Material values, ProtoDeclare and ExternProtoDeclare support, anchor links to HTML should get handed off to web browser | Public |
| horizon3.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | Universal Media Panoramas examples | Background textures, handle or ignore URN | Public |
| UserInteractivitySensorNodes.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | X3D for Web Authors examples scene to demonstrate user interaction (before and after images) | TouchSensor, PlaneSensor, CylinderSensor, SphereSensor, KeySensor and StringSensor | Public |
| CreateX3dFromStringRandomSpheres.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | X3D Basic examples scene to generate new X3D geometry using an embedded Script node | Script node, ECMAScript support for createX3dFromString function | Public |
| Gimbals.x3d | 21 February 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | X3D Basic examples scene to show coordinate-system rotation values | Shows Extrusion, Text, TouchSensor and Script nodes working together, also tests proper keyboard navigation using PgUp PgDn Home End keys. | Public |
| ViewpointGroupTest.x3d | 9 March 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | X3D Basic examples scene to demonstrate ViewpointGroup support | Shows ViewpointGroup nodes containing nested Viewpoints to support user navigation in large worlds. | Public |
| HelloEarth.x3d, HelloEarthOpenStreetMap.x3d and HelloEarthOpenAerialMap.x3d | 1 March 2009 | Byounghyun Yoo, Web3D Fellow | Geospatial Component scenes to demonstrate X3D Earth support | Shows GeoLOD imagery and terrain nodes from various sources for 7 to 17 levels of detail. | Public |
| NancyDiving.x3d | 1 March 2009 | Don Brutzman, NPS | HumanoidAnimation Component scene to demonstrate H-Anim support | Shows Nancy avatar scuba diving. | Public |
2009 Plugfest - March 2009 - Results
| X3D Scenes, X3D Viewers | BS Contact beta | FreeWRL, FreeX3D | Instant Player | Octaga | Vivaty | Xj3D |
| HelloWorld.x3d | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | fail, defaults to FLY mode | fail, incorrect Text vertical alignment |
| (earlier revision) Web3dLogo.x3d | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass |
| Web3DTimeline.x3d (still being improved) | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | ||
| LineProperties.x3d | fail | Pass | Pass | Pass | fail | Pass |
| FillProperties.x3d | fail | Pass | fail | Pass | fail | fail |
| SpringExamples.x3d | Pass | no ExternProtoDeclare support yet in XML parser interface code | Pass | Pass | crash | fail |
| horizon3.x3d | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | crash | Pass |
| UserInteractivitySensorNodes.x3d | Pass | Pass | All pass but StringSensor, since <enter> key goes full screen | Pass | KeySensor case error, StringSensor duplicates characters | Pass |
| CreateX3dFromStringRandomSpheres.x3d | fail | fail | fail | fail | fail | fail |
| Gimbals.x3d | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | crash | Works OK but Extrusion ends are warped |
| ViewpointGroupTest.x3d | fail, only shows Viewpoints | fail | OK except for nested ViewpointGroup | Pass | fail | fail |
| HelloEarth.x3d, HelloEarthOpenStreetMap.x3d and HelloEarthOpenAerialMap.x3d | fail | Pass | fail | fail | fail | Pass |
| NancyDiving.x3d (Script still being improved) | Pass | fail | crash | Pass | fail | No animation |
The X3D Plugfest was held at the Web3D Consortium Members Meeting, Wednesday 4 March 2009, at the NASA Ames research facility in Moffett Field, California.
Content
http://www.web3d.org/x3d/wiki/index.php/image:VT_examples.zip
2008
2008 Plugfest - 9 August 2008 - Web3D Symposium
| BS Contact | XJ3D | Swirl | Octaga | FreeWRL, FreeX3D | Vivaty | Instant Player | |
| City Scapes | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Clipping Issues | Pass | Pass |
| Hello World | Pass | Space Bet Image and Text | rotation off by -1x | Pass | Pass | failed n examine mode | Pass |
| Panoramic View | Pass | dropped down | outside the cylinder | dropped down | can't go up or down or front or back | didn't drop until u take step | shifted view and field |
| Gravity Effect | drop down until u move | Pass | no change until u move | Pass | no gravity | gravity kicks in only when u move | Pass |
| Virtual Museum | Pass | Pass | navigation failure | Pass | no gravity more pixelation | Pass | Pass |
| Inline View Point | Pass | wrong inline | Pass | does not keep track of view point | Pass | wrong in line | |
| Proto Instance | referenced | referenced | script does not work | copy | failed | copy | failed - same color |
| Moving Box | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass |
| Extrusion Text | Pass | inside out | y-axis off | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass |
| Top Level | Pass | top level nodes are implicit | Pass | Pass | mouse icon instead of text | Pass | Pass |
| Co-ordinate Morphs | Pass | Pass | initial view point is off | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| Color | Pass | Pass | color does not change | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass |
| Venus X3D | Pass | Pass | no environment mapping | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass |
| String X3D | vertical | horizontal | horizontal | horizontal | vertical | vertical | horizontal |
| Global Annotations | Pass | Pass | head lights on | Pass | does not support | Pass | failed |
| Script I/O Field | close | function | close | function |
Problematic Content
- Viewpoint-binding-0.x3d
- ViewpointInlineMain.x3d
- TopLevelTouchSensors.x3d
- String.x3d
- GlobalAttenuation.x3d
- Script-and-inputOutputField.x3d
Working Content
Issues
This is a summary of the issues discovered:
- User Initial Position without a Viewpoint
- Extrusion Implementations
- Node fields on a proto declaration, copy or reference
Instructions to submitters
Please upload your Plugfest content here. Be sure to create a single zip file with all the parts included. Each zip file will be verified for content.
The goal of the each X3D Plugfest is to foster interoperability between X3D players. Each Plugfest is a regular event that brings content authors, authoring tool vendors and browser implementers together to work on interoperability issues. Consistent quality for X3D content helps everyone.
This is the navigation home page for the upcoming X3D Plugfests. Content will be linked from this page for everyone's review.
Please note: Submitted .x3d files must be zipped before being uploaded. Alternatively, links to online content can be provided.
Description fields: Include a description of your content, or else a description of the problem and any results from the browsers you've tested.
Content Release Option: Specify whether the content can be released publicly or just distributed to browser implementers for testing.
Related links include:
